Formal and substantive equality introduction the principle of equality is a fundamental assumption of a democratic society. The formal model of equality adopts what can be called single standard rules. Formal equality advocates for the neutral treatment of all people based on the norms of the dominant group in society. Apparently consistent treatment infringes the goal of substantive equality if the results are unequal. Legal instruments currently embody a variety of conceptions of equality. A popular cartoon shows a child, still in his mothers womb, thinking, i hope daddy is sc, st and obc. Equality of opportunity stanford encyclopedia of philosophy. These limitations of the principle of formal or procedural equality have led to attempts to develop concepts of substantive equality. The equality duty is an example of adopting a substantive equality approach, because it requires. Weber defines formal rationality as the degree to an action happens as a result of quantitative and appropriate calculations weber, 1987. Pdf the limitations of a formal interpretation of the right to equality are now well recognized.
Indirect discrimination or disparate impact theory is a particularly valiant attempt to remedy the consequences of hierarchy that are otherwise reinforced by conventional equality theory. It presents a process of continuous improvement through which agencies can progress towards achieving substantive equality and meeting their obligations under the equal opportunity act. Substantive equality revisited international journal of. Formal equality is known as the formal, legal equality. The public sector commissioners circular 200923 outlines how departments are. This article considers the extent to which ec and uk equality law are moving away from liberal notions of nondiscrimination towards an approach based on substantive equality or equity, not only in the field of sex discrimination but also in respect of race and disability discrimination at a time when the ec is expanding its competence in these areas. The lcos approach to the concept of equality is substantive, rather than formal. However, the meaning of substantive equality remains deeply contested.
Substantive equality theorists thus embrace targeted interventions designed to equalize opportunity when they conclude that nominal formal equality cannot overcome institutional or other impediments to a truly fair system. Equal opportunity commission, government of western australia. This paper is to introduce webers formal and substantive rationality concepts, then to analyze how these two concepts are related to scientific management and human relation theory. Intersectional discrimination and substantive equality. What is the difference between formal and substantive equality. Formal and substantive principles of reason oxford scholarship. This deeply entrenched power imbalance, existing between men and women within a world that is predominantly defined by men, could preclude any assurance of formal equality, let alone substantive equality in any justice intervention. Oct 30, 2015 substantive justice and formal justice differ in that formal justices jurisdiction lies in the procedural domain of following rules, whereas substantive justice seeks to ensure that the rules themselves are fair. It is well recognised that a corollary exists between equality and nondiscrimination. Formal equality is an equality of men and women in the formal sense that is all are same and are subject to the same rules and regulations in social,political,economic and other areas of life. In effect they may be indirectly discriminatory, creating systemic discrimination.
Dec 20, 2017 it is now wellaccepted in south african constitutional jurisprudence that the constitutions guarantee of equality in section 9 is not merely concerned with formal equality equality at law, but endorses a notion of substantive equality. The first time substantive equality was argued to a court of law was by the womens. A comparative and theoretical perspective ben smith1 introduction our struggle for liberation has significance only if it takes place within a feminist movement that has as its fundamental goal the liberation of all people. Substantive equality equality is a complex concept. Rather than the universal, abstract individual of formal equality, substantive equality recognizes that individuals are essentially social. Gender equality manifested through antidiscrimination laws including provisions on equal opportunities, as interpreted by the ecj, cannot truly be of a substantive nature. Substantive equality gives opportunity of outcome and may recognize different situations or circumstances, whereas formal equality applies one rule to fit all people so that does not allow for any diversi. Substantive equality volume 59 issue 3 catherine barnard, bob hepple skip to main content accessibility help we use cookies to distinguish you from other users and to provide you with a better experience on our websites. These two types of equality impact corporate professionals on a daily basis because applying rules to unequal groups leads to.
This sets it apart from the equal treatment model, which prohibits classification on the prohibited grounds regardless of whether this favors or disfavors a disadvantaged group. Substantive equality cannot override formal equality. Fredman19 has identified four different, but overlapping approaches. Substantive gender equality requires that equality is interpreted according to the broad context or realities of womens disadvantages and the impact of these circumstances in terms of eliminating disadvantage in outcome or result. However, the meaning of substantive equality remains. Unlike formal equality, which dictates behaviour through applying. The tension between formal and substantive equality is missed here. Equality constitutional adjudication in south africa chapter. But substantive equality is not just another version of disparate impact. Substantive equality as an overarching value lcocdo.
Through directive 76207, the subsequent directives 200273 and 200654, the european community has the ambition of fighting inequalities between the sexes as regards access to employment, vocational training and promotion and working conditions. From formal to substantive gender equality formal gender equality refers to the adoption of laws and policies that guarantee equal treatment and opportunities for women and men, eliminating all instances of legal discrimination. The problem with formal equality of opportunity is that it is merely formal. Substantive equality the cambridge law journal cambridge core. This chapter lays out the principles of practical reason whose normativity the book defends, and distinguishes them from other proposed principles of practical reason. As you can see i consider substantive equality to have the same meaning as equity. This is the equality that is seen as one law should be applied to all people, social and personal characteristics are no factor.
Formal equality and substantive equality are two very different forms of equality. Substantive equality recognises that policies and practices put in place to suit the majority of clients may appear to be nondiscriminatory but may not address the specific needs of certain groups of people. Substantive equality and transformation in south africa. While formal equality typically carries negative duties e. This approach was inspired by early landmark constitutional cases in the united states, which broke away from formal approaches to.
This article argues that the right to substantive equality should not be collapsed into a single formula, such as dignity, or equality of opportunity or results. Substantive equality, unlike formal equality, rejects the mere presence or absence of difference as an answer to differential treatment. However, the meaning of substantive equality remains dee. Equality of outcomes 20 equality of outcomes is a substantive conception of equality, as it attempts to provide substance to the concept of equality. One of the key advances represented by substantive equality over formal equality, is that it is expressly asymmetric. Formal and substantive equality 1174 words 123 help me. Substantive equality means achieving equitable outcomes as well as equal opportunity, and the need to sometimes treat people differently to achieve equal. The principle of instrumental reason is interpreted broadly as the general principle of practical judgment or application. Question 5 explain the difference between formal or procedural equality and substantive equality. During the late 20th century, substantive equality originated in opposition to formal equality.
Substantive equality revisited international journal of constitutional. These two types of equality impact corporate professionals on a daily basis. Formal and substantive equality 1185 words bartleby. Article 2 of the convention enjoins the state to ensure the practical realization of rights. The paper traces the evolution of the concept of substantive equality in north american jurisprudence and suggests that feminist jurisprudence gave a new dimension to the understanding of substantive equality. Substantive equality revisited by sandra fredman ssrn. Oct 16, 2014 the limitations of a formal interpretation of the right to equality are now well recognized. Cedaw article 1 any distinction, exclusion or restriction m ad on the basis of sex. In this lesson, we discuss formal equality and substantive equality.
This document outlines the policy framework for achieving substantive equality in service provision of the public sector. Formal equality is, however, still the root of the provision, and it thus cannot be argued. Training manual on the convention on the elimination of all forms of discrimination against women. One distinction is between formal or procedural equality and substantive equality rosenfeld, 1986. Formal equality does not recognize difference, whereas substantive equality takes sex, race, ethnicity etc. Aug 26, 2017 i find illustrations to be quite clarifying. Substantive equality is a fundamental aspect of human rights law that is concerned with. The illustration at the right is substantive equality. Formal justice is concerned with treating like cases alike, and substantive justice must specify what counts as alike. Substantive moral principles, identified in terms of their distinctively moral content, are distinguished. Aristotles notion of equality influenced the conception of formal equality in.
As south africa celebrates 20 years of constitutionalism, it is timely to examine critically the south african constitutional courts approach to one of the central pillars in pursuit of a nonracial and nonsexist south africa. There is a range of information resources and tools to assist implementation of the the policy framework for substantive equality and for people to find out more about preventing systemic discrimination. What is substantive equality equal opportunity commission. Gender equality in european community law abstract. The second aspect of the participative dimension is to address the importance of community in the life of individuals. Public sector commissioners circular 200923 revised 01 february 2015. The limitations of a formal interpretation of the right to equality are now well recognized. It illustrates how formal equality of treatment merely. Formal and substantive equality 2 equal rights trust. Under the terms of the licence agreement, an individual user may print out a pdf of a single entry from a reference work in or for. Aristotelian formal equality approach revolving around sameness and. The supreme court of canada, in a recent case dealing with agebased criteria, stated that.
943 1072 276 1038 775 235 522 922 1534 1552 230 985 533 16 548 1328 69 764 551 1522 1012 492 25 365 1157 1014 1293 627 1101